How do you replace a lost mailbox key?
The safe fix for a lost mailbox key is a new lock with new keys, so the lost key stops working. Mailbox Lock and Repair does this for mailboxes you own, after a photo ID check, and for landlords and HOAs (homeowners associations) with written approval. For a Post Office-owned box, contact your local Post Office.
Who owns the mailbox you lost the key to?
Your mailbox belongs to you, your landlord or HOA, or the Post Office, and only the owner can get you a new lock and keys. A house mailbox usually belongs to the homeowner. Apartment mailboxes and cluster mailboxes (one metal unit with many locked mailboxes) belong to the property owner, the HOA or the Post Office.
- You own the home and the mailboxWe can replace the lock. Show photo ID with the same address as the mailbox.
- A landlord, HOA or building manager owns itThey order the work in writing (a house landlord may approve it instead). Then we can replace the lock.
- The Post Office owns itOnly the Post Office can change this lock. Contact your local Post Office.
Not sure? Ask whoever gave you your keys, or your local Post Office.
Still have your key, but it broke off in the lock or won't turn? That is a repair, not a lost key: see broken or stuck mailbox lock.
What should you do the day you lose a mailbox key?
Contact whoever owns the mailbox, because only the owner can have the lock changed:
| Your mailbox | Who to contact | What happens next |
|---|---|---|
| You own it (curbside, wall or door mailbox) | Us, for a new lock and keys | The technician checks photo ID with the same address as the mailbox, then fits a new lock. |
| You rent a house | Your landlord or property manager | They order or approve the new lock in writing (an email is fine). Then we can change it. |
| Apartment, condo or HOA box, privately owned | Your building manager or HOA | They handle the locks and may keep a spare key. If not, they order a new lock: see apartment and HOA mailbox locks. |
| Post Office-owned box | Your local Post Office | The Post Office keeps no spare keys. If you lost every key, it fits a new lock and keys at your cost; the charge is set locally. |
| PO Box | The Post Office where you rent the box | Only the Post Office handles PO Box keys. We never make them. |
The apartment and Post Office rows follow the USPS FAQ on locked mailboxes and keys.
Until the lock changes, keep new mail from piling up in a box you can't open: ask the Post Office to hold your mail with its Hold Mail service.
Why is a new lock better than a copied key?
A new lock makes the lost key useless, while a copy leaves it working for whoever has it. A copy also usually needs a working key to copy from, and you have none.
| Question | New lock and keys | Copied key |
|---|---|---|
| Does the lost key still open the mailbox? | No | Yes |
| Do you need a working key to start? | No | Usually |
| Do you know how many keys exist? | Yes: you get every new key | No |
| Does it fix a worn lock? | Yes | No |
That is why we don't cut spare keys: new keys always come with a new lock. We never make or copy postal keys either, meaning keys for the arrow lock (the mail carrier's master lock), Post Office-owned locks or PO Boxes. Federal law makes stealing a postal key, or making one unlawfully, a crime with up to ten years in prison (18 U.S.C. 1704).
How is a mailbox lock replaced without a key?
Without a key, the technician takes the old lock out with tools made for the job and fits a new lock with new keys. This happens only after the technician checks photo ID with the same address as the mailbox, or the owner's written order. Without one of those, nothing gets opened.
The new lock is made for your mailbox maker. The old lock is not reused, so the lost key opens nothing.
The ID check keeps strangers out of your mail, and breaking open a mailbox can be a federal crime (18 U.S.C. 1705). If the technician can't do the job because there is no photo ID, the visit is free: see our terms.
How long does mailbox key replacement take?
Mailbox key replacement takes one visit: the old lock comes out, and the new lock and keys go in. When you book, we confirm the address and a time window for the visit.
Tell us the mailbox maker if you know it, so we bring a lock that fits. Salsbury and other mailbox brands shows where to find the maker's name.
Renting? The slow part can be the paperwork, because your landlord's written OK has to come first. Ask for it the day you lose the key.
What affects the cost of replacing a lost mailbox key?
A new key means a new lock, so the price depends mostly on the lock your mailbox needs. Every quote is free and in writing, so you know the full price before any work starts.
What changes the price
- The lock: a standard mailbox cam lock, or a lock made for an apartment panel or cluster box
- The mailbox type and maker
- How many locks we change on one visit
- A key broken off inside the old lock
- An after-hours visit
What the price includes
- The new lock
- The new keys
- The visit
You get a free quote before any work starts, and the price is in writing. No fix, no fee: if we can't do the job, you pay nothing.
How does a lost mailbox key visit work?
The visit follows the usual steps, with one difference: you can't empty a mailbox you can't open. For a house mailbox, use Hold Mail so nothing new arrives, and once the old lock is out, take out any mail inside yourself before the new lock goes in.
For an apartment or HOA box, ask your manager, who may keep a spare key so you can empty it first. If there is no spare key, the manager should ask the local Post Office before the visit: see apartment and HOA mailbox locks.
- Ask for a quoteCall or send the form. Tell us the mailbox type, how many locks and what is wrong.
- Tell us who owns the mailboxYou, your landlord, HOA or building manager, or the Post Office. We only work on privately owned mailboxes.
- Get an arrival timeWe confirm the address and a time window. Please empty the mailbox before the visit. If you can't open it (lost key, stuck lock or a key broken inside), tell us when you book: once the old lock is off, you take out your own mail before any other work. We never handle mail. For an apartment or HOA box, the manager makes sure the box is empty first.
- Show photo ID or the written OKThe technician checks photo ID with the same address as the mailbox, or the owner's written order for a rental, an apartment building or an HOA.
- A matching lock goes inThe technician fits a lock made for your mailbox maker, with the right cam (the small metal arm on the back of the lock that holds the door shut).
- Test every key with youEach new key opens and locks the door before the technician leaves.
- Pay and get a receiptYou pay when the job is done and get a written receipt. No fix, no fee.
- Old keys stop workingThe old lock comes out, so a lost or copied old key no longer opens your mailbox.
What should you check before you hire anyone?
Use this list with any company, including us. Walk away from anyone who offers to copy a Post Office key or to open a mailbox without asking for ID.
- You get a written price with every fee before any work starts.
- They ask who owns the mailbox and check photo ID, or the owner's written OK for a rental.
- They refuse to work on Post Office-owned boxes, the arrow lock (the mail carrier's master lock) and parcel lockers (the bigger locked boxes for packages).
- They fit a lock that matches your mailbox maker, not a one-size-fits-all part.
- You get every new key and a receipt.
- They make no "USPS-approved" or "official" claims about their work. Some mailbox models carry USPS approval, but that says nothing about who changes the lock.
- Be careful with ads that say "$19 service call" or "from $35". The final bill is often much higher.
Lost mailbox key questions
Can you make a new mailbox key without changing the lock?
No. We don't cut spare keys or copy keys: a new key always comes with a new lock. That way the lost key stops working, and you know every key that exists.
My wallet with my ID and mailbox key was stolen. What should I do?
Change the lock soon, because the thief may now have your address and your key. We still need photo ID with the same address as the mailbox, so get a replacement ID before you book. Until then, use Hold Mail so new mail waits at the Post Office, and report any missing mail to the U.S. Postal Inspection Service.
Can the Post Office give me a new mailbox key?
Only for a mailbox the Post Office owns. It keeps no spare keys, so if you lose every key, it fits a new lock with new keys at your cost. For a mailbox you or your landlord own, the lock and keys are the owner's job.
I lost the key to my locking mailbox on a rural route. Can you replace the lock?
Yes, if the mailbox was made to lock. On rural and highway contract routes (roadside routes served by a rural carrier or a Post Office contractor), the USPS manual bans adding locks to ordinary curbside mailboxes, so we never do that. A locking mailbox also needs a slot big enough for your normal daily mail.